by Lilkanga » Wed Apr 28, 2010 4:32 pm
Snickers,
You ask a great question here when you write:
"Is it at all possible to understand this issue today? Is it at all possible to prove exactly what the proper calendar is today?"
I have an answer to your question as well as a suggestion for all of us to consider.
The answer to your questions are this. At this time, it probably is not possible for us to understand YHWH calendar and certainly we can not prove the exactness of His Appointed Times, (and here is the key), without His divine intervention.
Now before I bring up my suggestion for the leadership of CI to chew on, allow me to lay a little ground work.
First of all, just because we do not have the fullness of understanding concerning YHWH's calendar, does not mean that YHWH's Feast are not important to keep. If there is one thing that I have learned in my lifetime of keeping YHWH's Feast it would be that YHWH does not grant perfect (that is to say, fullness of) understanding on any subject right off. He brings us into a little light to see what we will do with that little bite of truth. If we act on that truth to His satisfaction, then he will shed more light on the subject, then a little more and so on, until one day, we come to see it so clearly, we wonder how we was so deceived before.
Just like Christian Identity. How come I never saw this before? I knew who Israel is? But, I just was not ready to see,,,,,right?
As a body, in the past few years, none of us were ready to see YHWH's calendar in its fullness.
Now, if i may introduce my suggestion with a question.
According to scripture, how was it that YHWH revealed truth to men of Israel? It is a subtle answer found in the story of David and Saul in 1Sam. 28:6.
There are three ways in which YHWH answered questions (inquiries) from that of Israel.
1) By Dream
2) By Prophet
3) By Urim
Now, I think we understand 1and 2 pretty well. I've not heard of anyone (and it would have to be two or three people at the same time) having a dream spelling out the calendar and I know of no prophets that YHWH has sent telling us how the calendar should be.
It is number 3 that I feel we might be able to glean information.
The Urim, points to the Urim and Thummim of the Levitical priesthood, something that we do not have today. A close study of this subject will show that this was nothing more than the casting of lots to retrieve judgments from YHWH Himself.
Is that not we are seeking today? A Judgment from YHWH on how to keep His calendar?
I consider myself an expert on YHWH's calendar, and yet, I do not know when a day begins or ends. Nor when exactly a month begins, or when the year begins, which are all starting points for us to count toward YHWH Appointments. Oh, I can tell you every way possible to calculate YHWH's calendar, but knowing for sure which way is correct.......None of us knows!!!!
Now, how can we know?
How about asking YHWH directly? Has anyone thought to do that? Consider these passages from Proverbs, with the understanding that there is division (also known as contention) with in the assemblies over the calendar.
Proverbs 18:18 "Casting lots causes contentions to cease and keeps the mighty apart."
and
Proverbs 16:33 "The lot is cast into the lap but its every answer is from YHWH."
From these two passages alone we can glean the following points
1) There are contentions between the mighty (leaders of the assemblies)
2) The casting of lots puts a stop to these contentions, bringing unity to the body.
3) There has to be division before the lot can be cast.
4) The lot cast into the lap, points to both parties being in the right attitude of humbleness (more on this latter)
5) YHWH promises to answer and YHWH can not lie, so what will come from this is the truth.
Now back quickly to the urim and thummim. Think about this. israel has Moses, Aaron and all the Elders of the tribes of Israel, not to mention Joshua waiting in the wings. Yet, YHWH thought it best to give them the process of the Urim and Thummin.
Why?
Because, even with great men of knowledge and valor, there are still cases when only YHWH wisdom and knowledge and understanding can answer a matter.
Today, we find ourselves in just such a matter. We are separated from the true meaning of the Hebrew language. Yes we have Strongs and great scholars that get us close, but at the end of the day we all have our western mindsets that keep us from coming to a fullness of truth on the Old Testament scriptures.
We need YHWH's judgment of this matter.
Also consider what Philo wrote on the Urim and Thummim. And remember Philo was a Levite, not a Jew.
"And first of all is speaks thus of anger (something we all tend to have when debating the calendar), in the hope of passivizing and curing it. Moses wrote, And you shall put manifestation and truth, the urim and thummim, in the oracle of judgment and it shall be on the breast of Aaron when he comes into the Holy Place before YHWH. now by the oracle is here meant the organs of speech which exist in us, which is in fact the power of language (which we today have lost sight of, we do not own the power of the Hebrew language). Now language is either inconsiderate and such as will not stand examination or else it is judicious and well approved and brings us to form a nation of discreet speech. For Moses here speaks not of a random spurious oracle, but of the oracle of the Judgment of YHWH, which is equivalent to saying, a well judged and careful examination of the oracle." Allegorical Interpretation III XL (118-119).
From this I gather that even with the greatest of men in Israel's History at Israel's judgment, there was still times that matters exceeded even their understanding, even with perfect knowledge of the Hebrew language and so that anger was kept low, YHWH gave Israel the judgment via the urim and thummim.
It is my opinion that YHWH wills for us to humble ourselves, putting our own doctrines and thoughts aside to inquire of Him with a right lowly attitude that says, I will believe what Proverbs says and know that YHWH will answer this question of lot and I will change my own theology accordingly.....no matter what.
Consider what YHWH has to say in Zeph. 1:3 and 6:
" I will consume man and beast", "......Those who have not sought YHWH, nor inquired of Him."
How can we say that we have sought after Him and His ways, if we have not inquired of Him the scriptural way?
Now, there are two ways to accomplish this.
1) Have the leading men of CI pray and fast for a period of time, then come together and have a meeting (like a council of Elders meeting, such as they did in Acts 15), agreeing on the form of lot they wish to use and agreeing before YHWH that all will adhere to the answers given.
or
2) 1Chronicles 26 tells the story of how the gatekeepers were chosen in ancient Israel from the tribes of Levi. Anyone who has studied the calendar knows the importance of the east gate of the temple in Ezk. 46:1-3. Thus the gatekeepers called the calendar. The gatekeepers were chosen by lot. If we have not lost total faith in YHWH working through a man, then our faith might better be served by coming together as prescribed above and choosing a man to call the calendar, having complete faith that YHWH will reveal to that man, whom YHWH would have ultimately chosen, the ins and outs of the calendar.
Also, please note that whenever lots are cast that a "no answer" should be included in the choices that YHWH has to choose from. Thus if He does not will for us to know at this time, that "no answer" will come up. Or if none of the answers are given correctly. This is scriptural from the very passage I quoted above, when YHWH did not answer Saul, not even by Urim. Thus it is scriptural to have a no answer in the lot.
Blessings to you all in the name of YHWH and may Isa. 52:8 come to pass right now in this group.
Joey