This Forum is now inactive and has been replaced by a new Christogenea Forum. You may browse here but there are no updated threads or new posts since January 1st 2017. Forum members please see THIS NOTICE for information concerning your account at the new forum.

Can a guerilla/insurgent force defeat a conventional army?

Just keep it lawful.

Re: Can a guerilla/insurgent force defeat a conventional arm

Postby MichaelAllen » Tue Jul 16, 2013 7:29 pm

learningaboutCI wrote:My gut reaction is that an insurgency "wins" when the press is brought to bear on their side. Otherwise, no. Image and perception strike me as fundamental to outcomes. Not to mention starts! In other words, if the Jews want the "insurgency" to "win", then that's what the papers will gradually work toward.


In accordance with what I perceive Brother Bill's wishes to be, I will keep this as vague as possible, but I will give a few hypothetical scenarios for folks to consider.

The quotation I've copied from learningaboutCI is of no small significance.

As a former Marine Corps rifleman, I have personal struggles with some of Yahweh's promises in the law about military operations. I will never understand why He allowed the Third Reich to fall to the antichrist international talmudic jews, who were in control of the Allied nations and of course the USSR. Some will chalk it up to God's timing. Personally, I have a very difficult time buying that.

I will also never understand why God allowed old Saxon England to lose the war against the Normans in 1066. The Norman dynasty was in bed with the jewish moneychangers, and the English were actually keeping Yahweh's law in a national setting. Why the Normans were permitted to be victors when England was a very righteous and Christian society perplexes me when I read the passages about Yahweh guaranteeing victory to those who are obedient to the law. Here are two cases where the law did not produce the results that we are told.

The only thing I can surmise is that much of the divine law must be understood in terms of its practicality. We must understand it as it would take place in real life, not on some theoretical level, then we just expect something magical... or miraculous... to happen without our serious involvement. For instance... God told Israel to take the land, but to spy it out first. That implies personal initiative. The laws of Yahweh are, in my opinion, the practicality of probability. Somewhere in between understanding the law theoretically, having the correct data, intelligence, and insight, our activity is required. In so doing we must seek to appropriate the promises of God.

Ultimately, dominion is the responsibility (or liability) of our Israel kindred. So long as we do not accept that, we will face the problems associated with giving it over to antichrists.

So to the OP's question. Is it possible that an insurgency can fight off a conventional army? That depends upon every factor in the equation. There is no simple 2 + 2 = 4 when we discuss this issue. The equation cannot be simplified. It's more like a polynomial with unknown variables and unrelated mathematical terms.

I know that many among our ranks will disagree with me on this point, but I can tell you that I still have infrequent contact with members of the Armed Services and I know how most of them feel about our government. One particular friend of mine talks about his reserve drill weekends... where all they do is sit around and talk about what they plan on doing if martial law were ever declared. Based upon the things I hear, I am highly suspicious that the military bases would be looted before any career General could carry out a massive search and seizure or other kind of martial law operation in a neighborhood near you. I have met commissioned officer pilots who said they would steal their assigned aircraft lol!!

Factor this, there are more members of the United States military now who are no longer serving than there are who are serving. Most of them are very cynical about the Global War on Terror, and a good bunch of them know that 9/11 was a set up. Most of these veterans, if they served in the last 10 years, participated in at least two hostile zone deployments where often times they were sitting ducks. We learned a lot from our enemies. There are people all over our country now who know how to make weapons catastrophic enough to knock out tanks from non-traditional components like the Iraqi/Afghani insurgents do. The elite are often their own worst enemy. They often make decisions that come back to bite them in the ass later. They basically trained United States service members (again, who are mostly now civilians) how to defeat a bigger, more equipped occupational force.

Add to that the fact that there are more honest and justice-minded people who hate the United States government today than at any time in our history, and they have every right to be outraged.

Some will point to Hurricane Katrina and say, "See, the military confiscated weapons!!! They'll do it!!! They'll do it!!!" But I can say with assurance that this was an isolated incident, and it went over like a fart in church with the American public. It has also been a massive talking point among enlisted troops.

I believe Katrina was a testing grounds of sort to see whether or not U.S. troops would obey weapons confiscation orders... however, the elite have sort of forgotten that with the advent of the world wide web, it is much easier for there to be serious exposure on issues such as this, and I sense very strongly that our troops will not abide this kind of order again.

Let's look at two scenarios, which we will call A and B.

(A) Defensive posture - The powers that be decide to initiate a martial law order of some sort. What I hear about much in the patriot movement, truth-movement, conspiracy theory movements, etc... most of what I hear is idle talk about defensive posture, "If they come for my guns... blah blah blah." While I believe that this would be a crucial line in the sand (just like Lexington Green), the elite have us right where they want us, and for them to actually move to that point now wouldn't really serve a purpose and would demonstrate insanity. I don't think they are insane. I think they are wicked.

So right out of the gate, I believe that scenario (A) is highly improbable. However, if it were to occur, toe to toe, I believe that the defection in the ranks of military personnel and the length of time that it would take a sizable military force to pacify and disarm the American public would be too long and too many things can go wrong. Here are three sub-points for your consideration:

1.) On the front end, most people don't realize this, but on military bases, the personnel are NOT armed. All munitions are withdrawn from a supply depot on the base somewhere and that is generally one single location per base. Now, consider what I've told you about how many troops feel negatively about martial law. Consider that there are people currently serving for NO OTHER REASON than to be a monkeywrench in a plan if something were to be unveiled (which I don't think is really happening). It wouldn't take a lot of motivation to completely interrupt the ability of an entire divisional unit to be without sufficient ammunition.

2.) In the middle of it, even if a sizeable unit were deployed, there will be internal problems that troops refuse to fire on Americans or confiscate weapons.

3.) On the back end, the time to successfully deploy will be subverted by our modern forms of instant communication. That unit is going to have members texting, sending out information about the unit's location and destination right on their blogs. It wouldn't take a serious effort for a group of local citizens to meet with the local police/sheriff and declare their intent and demand their support. The local citizens know where these cops and local politicans live. Should they placate and give in to the occupational force's whims, they are going to have serious ramifications after that occupational force leaves.

I just don't see it happening from a defensive point of view.

Let's consider scenario (B), the offensive posture. The biggest problem I would see in an insurgent force attempting to thwart U.S. government control is just exactly what learningaboutCI stated... the media and perception. There is a public relations proverb that states: "Feelings are facts." Identity Christians know this all too well. You can't get through to some people. I don't think that most Americans are capable of understanding what you would be doing if you began eliminating targets. On top of that, we could take a poll right now and ask 100 different people what the best way to mount an offensive measure would be, and we would have at least 30 different opinions on this.

Insurgency is an invisible offense. It is the act of carrying out paramilitary operations against an enemy. Psychological warfare is a huge part of this. Most of the people in standard anti-government movements are not offensive-minded by nature. They are sheep who want the wolves to stop eating them. In an offensive situation, you become the hunter, and most of our people, including myself, feel very uncomfortable in that role.

You cannot underestimate the degree to which the establishment will respond to offensive moves. They will most likely not respond immediately in a forceful way, though they would speak with a lot of intent. Most offensive groups are idiots, I mean... seriously, which is why I avoid such people like the plague. They are very dumb and they are very poorly organized, and they most often wind up in jail or some kind of mental ward.

The other problem is that if you actually know who is control of the establishment, you know that they are masters at the dialectic. They can spin anything you do in their media and make people believe anything they want them to believe. It would take a very, very long time to have any kind of offensive success. You can pretty much take the Turner Diaries and chuck them to the wind. It could not happen like that. Subversion, agents provocateur, co-agitators, moles, etc... There would have to be a very small inner group with a funding source that could never be made known. Essentially, an offensive-minded insurgency would have to start with a secret society and they would have to act like jews to get anything done, and that would never happen among our Israelite folks for two reasons. 1.) We're not jews. 2.) We can't keep our stupid mouths shut about anything we know. Do you know how most people are caught by government agencies? They can't keep their mouths shut. They get away with something but then they tell their wife, and it leaks out.

I don't mean to be hard on our womenfolk, but Yahweh didn't design our sisters, wives, mothers, and daughters to be information retention devices. Women LOVE gossip, and sadly, we men LOVE to give them the ammunition with which to go gossiping.

Several years ago, I was working in a business where I unfortunately had to be around some jews. I noticed something very interesting about them... this was even before I was CI. I noticed that they don't talk business with their families. The men just make small talk with their women. They talk about pop-culture or lighter subjects. They don't sit and talk about how they are going to rip off the next corporation and drop a business deal and write it off as someone else's problem. It's just another day at the office for them.

My point is, the lesson we can learn here... even though CI is not a covert paramilitary operation, I don't think it is wise for us to include our women in certain discussions. Women are not our partners, they are our assistants (helpmeets), and that means not bringing them in for a "board of directors" meeting.

This cannot happen at this time in America with ANY degree of success. The media is the control mechanism that prevents that.
MichaelAllen
 
Posts: 253
Joined: Mon Jul 08, 2013 1:35 pm

Re: Can a guerilla/insurgent force defeat a conventional arm

Postby SwordBrethren » Tue Jul 16, 2013 10:25 pm

MichaelAllen wrote:
As a former Marine Corps rifleman, I have personal struggles with some of Yahweh's promises in the law about military operations. I will never understand why He allowed the Third Reich to fall to the antichrist international talmudic jews, who were in control of the Allied nations and of course the USSR. Some will chalk it up to God's timing. Personally, I have a very difficult time buying that.





God didn't allow the Third Reich to fall, He left it to His people in the USA, Britain, and the Commonwealth, to decide for themselves the right thing to do. They elected to follow the Jews and they brought about hell on Earth when they handed over half of the world to the communist Jews and put the rest of the world firmly into the hands of the capitalist Jews

If America and Britain had been populated by truly God-loving/God-fearing Bible believing Christians, there would never have been a Second World War, except perhaps the possibility that they would have sent forces to help Germany check and then crush the Soviet Union.
Revelation 18:
Und ich hörte eine andere Stimme vom Himmel, die sprach: Gehet aus von ihr, mein Volk, daß ihr nicht teilhaftig werdet ihrer Sünden, auf daß ihr nicht empfanget etwas von ihren Plagen!

Denn ihre Sünden reichen bis in den Himmel, und Gott denkt an ihren Frevel.


Judentum ist Verbrechertum!

Heute ist Deutschland die größte Weltmacht! - Der Führer 30 Januar 1940
User avatar
SwordBrethren
 
Posts: 423
Joined: Sun Nov 01, 2009 11:58 pm

Re: Can a guerilla/insurgent force defeat a conventional arm

Postby MichaelAllen » Tue Jul 16, 2013 10:57 pm

Staropramen wrote:
Kentucky wrote:Or even more succinctly: Can Christian Identity Defeat the Jew? I think so.

Mark


Absolutely!



Agreed!! Ours is a war of civilization, not of public policies that we don't like... which were basically the scenarios in my previous post.

CI is an intellectual war and one of concepts. Yahweh is already fighting for us. I have been in this message for 5 years, and I have already noticed that eyes are opening, ears are hearing, and hearts are receiving that just 5 years ago were closed to these great truths.

Intellectual wars can span several generations.
MichaelAllen
 
Posts: 253
Joined: Mon Jul 08, 2013 1:35 pm

Re: Can a guerilla/insurgent force defeat a conventional arm

Postby Kentucky » Wed Jul 17, 2013 12:27 am

SwordBrethren wrote:God didn't allow the Third Reich to fall, He left it to His people in the USA, Britain, and the Commonwealth, to decide for themselves the right thing to do. They elected to follow the Jews and they brought about hell on Earth when they handed over half of the world to the communist Jews and put the rest of the world firmly into the hands of the capitalist Jews

If America and Britain had been populated by truly God-loving/God-fearing Bible believing Christians, there would never have been a Second World War, except perhaps the possibility that they would have sent forces to help Germany check and then crush the Soviet Union.

That reminded me of Joseph and the betrayal by his brothers. The real losers of WWII was us; look at what we've got.... a famine of hearing the Word. "All things work together for good, for those who are called and love God." Germany is one of the called. When all of the called love God and are in agreement with His Law, then a victory is in sight. There is also the thought that because Esau was tricked out of his birthright, God is giving him a chance to bring forth the fruits of the Kingdom, even though it is impossible. But, the genius of God is that every jew must be so arrogantly minded towards self-deification, that that is the only justifiable means by which they can be divinely exterminated once and for all. Jewry had not yet developed a fulfilled 'Messiah Complex' in the 1930's. Fast forward to the present, and White people are beginning to see the jew as a threat to the entire world. Therefore, when they finally are exterminated, there will be rejoicing.

Mark
User avatar
Kentucky
 
Posts: 1803
Joined: Tue Jan 31, 2012 2:20 am

Re: Can a guerilla/insurgent force defeat a conventional arm

Postby Kentucky » Wed Jul 17, 2013 12:52 am

MichaelAllen wrote:I know that many among our ranks will disagree with me on this point, but I can tell you that I still have infrequent contact with members of the Armed Services and I know how most of them feel about our government. One particular friend of mine talks about his reserve drill weekends... where all they do is sit around and talk about what they plan on doing if martial law were ever declared. Based upon the things I hear, I am highly suspicious that the military bases would be looted before any career General could carry out a massive search and seizure or other kind of martial law operation in a neighborhood near you. I have met commissioned officer pilots who said they would steal their assigned aircraft lol!!

Remember the DC Snipers? Two Mutt n Jeff niggers shooting from an improvised back seat and trunk of a car. I'm sure the thought occurred to some of our ex military that jew TV and radio cannot function without transmitters. But putting that aside, let's not forget an even more formidable force: the American hunter. I'm sure you'll find this article fascinating:

https://www.facebook.com/notes/john-gau ... 0852382984


Mark
User avatar
Kentucky
 
Posts: 1803
Joined: Tue Jan 31, 2012 2:20 am

Re: Can a guerilla/insurgent force defeat a conventional arm

Postby wmfinck » Wed Jul 17, 2013 6:55 am

MichaelAllen wrote: I will never understand why He allowed the Third Reich to fall to the antichrist international talmudic jews, who were in control of the Allied nations and of course the USSR. Some will chalk it up to God's timing. Personally, I have a very difficult time buying that.


Daniel 12:1 wrote: And at that time shall Michael stand up, the great prince which standeth for the children of thy people: and there shall be a time of trouble, such as never was since there was a nation even to that same time: and at that time thy people shall be delivered, every one that shall be found written in the book.


Michael is not an angel here, but an epithet, "Who is like God?"
Image
If a jew is moving his lips, he's lying. If you see a rabbi, there has already been a crime!
User avatar
wmfinck
Site Admin
 
Posts: 2775
Joined: Fri Jul 03, 2009 2:09 am

Re: Can a guerilla/insurgent force defeat a conventional arm

Postby Nayto » Wed Jul 17, 2013 4:50 pm

SwordBrethren wrote:God didn't allow the Third Reich to fall, He left it to His people in the USA, Britain, and the Commonwealth, to decide for themselves the right thing to do. They elected to follow the Jews and they brought about hell on Earth when they handed over half of the world to the communist Jews and put the rest of the world firmly into the hands of the capitalist Jews

If America and Britain had been populated by truly God-loving/God-fearing Bible believing Christians, there would never have been a Second World War, except perhaps the possibility that they would have sent forces to help Germany check and then crush the Soviet Union.


Great point. I hadn't thought of it that way before.
Nayto
 
Posts: 1151
Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2012 6:06 am

Re: Can a guerilla/insurgent force defeat a conventional arm

Postby Rogue » Tue Nov 19, 2013 7:50 pm

In the Irish war of Independence the tactic of flying columns were used, but it was necessary to have the backing of the people to be successful, to hide and assist in operations.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_War_of_Independence

But i dont believe that its even possible today to get a resistance off the ground,(if one were that way inclined) especially with the technology available, e.g. tracking devices hid in shoes, weapons and clothing, not to mention listing devices and cameras the size of a pin, alos the abundence of informants doesnt help.

YAHWEH is our only hope, and He will deliver, so be it.
One King, One Faith, One Law.
User avatar
Rogue
 
Posts: 87
Joined: Sat Jan 19, 2013 11:44 am

Re: Can a guerilla/insurgent force defeat a conventional arm

Postby Lang » Wed Nov 20, 2013 11:23 am

Americans are always left out of the equation when the objectives are jewish. I was there and I saw the utter waste and financial drain of the whole effort there. We were there for rubber; that's why the French were there before us. It was also Marxist dialectics in operation to change America economically and spiritually. I was involved in the Chu Hoi program, which was a surrender of arms. The thing is: one day the gook was ARVN and the next day he was VC. It was never about the 'domino theory' being that communists within our own government were giving our troops orders to stand down and taking away our ammo. Hanoi was serviced by Mobile and other big gas companies. It was all about the love of mammon and when I got out in 1971 at the ripe old age of 21, I was livid about the causes of war and began research, which led me to National Socialism and a few years later... Christian Identity.


I didn't know you had fought in the war, Mark. Thats cool. I don't think the americans lost the war to the vietnamese, I think the americans lost the war in the homefront, to the communists inside your own country fighting against americans. Just like Germany also didn't lose WW1 to the french, but because of the commies breaking the fighting spirit and putting Germany down.
"Give a hammer to a white, and he will build civilization;
Give a hammer to an asian, and he will build other hammers;
Give a hammer to an arab, and he will kill his wife;
Give a hammer to a nigger, and he will kill whites;
Give a hammer to a jew, and he will sell it to niggers.
"

J.M.
User avatar
Lang
 
Posts: 536
Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2013 1:30 pm
Location: Southern Brazil

Re: Can a guerilla/insurgent force defeat a conventional arm

Postby Kentucky » Wed Nov 20, 2013 12:25 pm

Lang wrote:I didn't know you had fought in the war, Mark.

I never really "fought" anything over there, being a reluctant draftee, I could clearly see through the military/industrial complex, although I was ignorant of the jewish problem. I contracted spinal meningitis in basic training and thought I would get out on a medical, however they kept me in, so I initiated a Congressional investigation of how this widespread disease in a number of forts in the US could happen; and guys dropping like flies. For this, I received my orders for Nam. This was the beginning of my hatred towards the government and the awakening wrath of a Saxon. To this day, the cream of the crop of White warriors are used as cannon fodder. There is nothing to fight, under jewish masters, except the jews themselves. Exterminationist? Hell yeah!!!!

Mark
User avatar
Kentucky
 
Posts: 1803
Joined: Tue Jan 31, 2012 2:20 am

PreviousNext

Return to Self-defence and military

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests

cron